Mixing Metals in Kitchen and Bath Design: Do’s and Don’ts
When it comes to remodeling your kitchen or bathroom, the big decisions, like cabinets, countertops and tile, usually get most of the attention. But the smaller details, like fixtures and hardware, are what bring the whole design together. And one of the most common questions we hear in Germantown, Cedarburg and Mequon is: “Is it okay to mix metals?”
The short answer? Yes! Mixing finishes like brass, chrome and matte black can give your kitchen or bathroom depth and personality while still looking cohesive. But it does take a little planning. Here are some do’s and don’ts to help guide your design.
Do: Pick a Dominant Metal
Think of your dominant metal as the “lead role” in your design. This finish should show up most often throughout the space so everything feels consistent. The other finishes play supporting roles, adding contrast and interest.
For example, if you choose brushed nickel for your cabinet pulls and faucets, you can layer in matte black pendant lights above the island or brass sconces near the vanity mirror. This keeps the design grounded while giving it dimension.
Real-life example: In a Cedarburg kitchen remodel, we used polished chrome for the bulk of the fixtures, but added brass hardware and a matte black vent hood. The chrome kept the space timeless, while the brass and black gave it warmth and modern edge.
Do: Limit Your Palette to 2-3 Finishes
Less is more when it comes to mixing metals. Two finishes will usually give you enough contrast without overwhelming the space. Three can work beautifully too, especially when one is subtle, like stainless steel appliances that naturally blend into the mix.
Here’s how this might play out in a bathroom remodel: brass fixtures on your vanity, matte black cabinet hardware and a chrome showerhead and trim kit. It feels intentional, not scattered.
Pro tip: In a Germantown bathroom, we paired matte black hardware with brushed brass mirrors. Stainless steel on the shower frame provided a neutral third option that balanced the room without distracting from the main finishes.
Don’t: Split the Room in Half
One mistake we see often is dividing the room visually…like making one wall all brass and the other all chrome. Instead, you’ll want to repeat your finishes in a balanced way across the space.
That might mean carrying brass into both your kitchen hardware and pendant lights, or repeating matte black in both your faucet and your vanity pulls. The key is weaving the metals throughout, so your eye naturally moves around the room instead of feeling like the space is chopped into sections.
Do: Consider the Style of Your Home
Not every finish works for every style. Part of mixing metals successfully is matching the finishes to the overall vibe of your remodel.
Matte black feels sleek and works well in modern, industrial or farmhouse-style kitchens and bathrooms.
Brass brings elegance and warmth, perfect for traditional or transitional spaces.
Chrome and polished nickel are timeless and versatile, giving you a classic look that pairs well with almost anything.
Example: In a Mequon kitchen remodel, a homeowner wanted a farmhouse feel. We used matte black hardware and lighting, paired with brushed brass faucets for warmth. The combo felt modern but still inviting.
Don’t Forget About Maintenance
Here’s something people don’t always think about: finishes don’t just look different, they behave differently too. Chrome and polished finishes tend to show water spots and fingerprints more easily, while brushed or matte finishes hide wear better.
If you’ve got a busy family in Richfield or Germantown, you might not want high-polish chrome handles that show smudges every time someone makes a snack. On the flip side, if you’re going for sleek and glossy, you may decide it’s worth the extra wipe-downs.
At KMKB, we’ll help you weigh the look and the lifestyle factor so your remodel isn’t just beautiful…it’s practical, too.
Final Thoughts: Mixing Metals with Confidence
Mixing metals doesn’t have to be intimidating. With a little planning, you can create kitchens and bathrooms that feel stylish, layered and uniquely yours. Whether you’re dreaming of a brass faucet paired with matte black cabinet pulls or you want a clean blend of chrome and stainless steel, the key is balance.
At Kettle Moraine Kitchen and Bath, we’ve helped families across Cedarburg, Germantown and Mequon design spaces that look incredible and function even better. We’ll work with you to choose finishes that reflect your style, fit your budget, and hold up to everyday life.
Ready to start your remodel? Reach out today, we’d love to help you mix metals like a pro.
